There’s one query that usually confronts enterprise capital companies as they develop extra profitable and encounter new alternatives: Ought to we register with the Securities and Alternate Fee (SEC)? Whereas there isn’t any one-size-fits-all response, and every agency will determine based mostly by itself set of information and circumstances, the present regulatory atmosphere and the SEC’s supercharged agenda are key elements to think about within the face of this query in the present day. On this put up, we briefly assessment the registration and exemption evaluation relevant to most of our VC shoppers and spotlight the important thing advantages and prices of turning into a registered funding adviser (RIA).
A observe to our non-US shoppers: The registration and exemption evaluation is totally different for managers which are based mostly outdoors the US. The appliance of the varied regulatory necessities additionally will rely upon the place your funds are organized. Please contact us for extra info.
Registration fundamentals for VC companies
Underneath the Funding Advisers Act of 1940 (Advisers Act), an funding adviser is any one that – for compensation – engages within the enterprise of offering recommendation to others relating to securities. Except for household places of work and company enterprise capital companies (CVCs), most VC companies will meet the definition of funding adviser. Anybody who falls inside the definition of funding adviser is required to register except an exemption applies. The primary exemption for VC companies is the enterprise capital adviser exemption, though smaller companies, particularly when first beginning out, additionally might depend on the non-public fund adviser exemption.
The enterprise capital adviser exemption exempts from registration funding advisers that solely advise a number of enterprise capital funds. The Advisers Act defines a enterprise capital fund as a kind of personal fund that represents to traders that it pursues a enterprise capital technique, gives redemption rights solely in extraordinary circumstances, doesn’t borrow greater than 15% of its combination capital contributions and uncalled capital commitments, and holds not more than 20% of its property in nonqualifying investments (also known as the 20% basket), with the remaining 80% restricted to investments in qualifying portfolio firms. Money and money equivalents don’t depend towards the 20% basket. A personal fund is an funding car that’s not provided to most people and is proscribed both to 100 useful homeowners or to useful homeowners which are certified purchasers (which incorporates entities with $25 million in investments and people with $5 million in investments).
The non-public fund adviser exemption exempts from registration funding advisers that solely advise non-public funds and have lower than $150 million in gross property underneath administration – often known as regulatory property underneath administration (RAUM) – throughout all their funds. Whereas topic to a cap on its RAUM, a personal fund adviser will not be restricted to advising enterprise capital funds and might advise any sort of personal funds, together with non-public fairness, crypto, hedge and others. A VC agency can depend on one or each of those exemptions, though it should doubtless outgrow the non-public fund adviser exemption over time. At that time, except all of its shoppers are non-public funds that meet the enterprise capital fund definition, the adviser might want to register with the SEC. An adviser that depends on both exemption is known as an exempt reporting adviser (ERA). ERAs are required to file parts of the Type ADV Half 1A with the SEC and adjust to restricted necessities underneath the Advisers Act, and they’re topic to examination by the Division of Examinations. Nonetheless, they aren’t “registered” with the SEC.
What are the advantages of registering?
The most important good thing about registering is flexibility. Advisers that depend on the enterprise capital adviser exemption or the non-public fund adviser exemption can discover themselves forgoing sure alternatives or funding buildings, negotiating much less favorable phrases, or taking up threat and coping with uncertainties. They’ve to choose between the costly and time-consuming strategy of registering and the regulatory burden that comes with it, or restrict themselves to making sure all their funds – together with any particular objective automobiles (SPVs) they handle – meet the enterprise capital fund definition (together with with respect to the 20% basket) or keep under $150 million of RAUM.
Maybe essentially the most important limitation for enterprise capital advisers is the cap on nonqualifying investments. Basically, qualifying investments are restricted to fairness investments acquired instantly from non-public working firms. Debt securities, securities acquired in secondary transactions (together with from founders and firm workers), public firm securities, cryptocurrencies and pursuits in different enterprise capital funds are among the many frequent nonqualifying investments that want to slot in the 20% basket. By registering, a enterprise capital adviser would not be constrained by the 20% basket, which, along with releasing up capability in its predominant funds for nonqualifying investments, can also show particularly impactful on the use and nature of SPVs that spend money on such nonqualifying investments. Registering additionally would imply that the adviser may advise funds that borrow in extra of the 15% restrict or allow traders to redeem outdoors of extraordinary circumstances.
Registration additionally permits elevated flexibility to tackle non-private fund shoppers, resembling individually managed accounts, household places of work and worker funds that aren’t non-public funds. For companies trying to discover new enterprise strains and totally different asset lessons, or enter into joint ventures, registration might present much-needed latitude.
Lastly, some companies might discover that sure traders are extra prepared to decide to a fund suggested by a RIA than an ERA. Whereas registration doesn’t impose a heightened commonplace of fiduciary obligation (ERAs are topic to the identical commonplace of conduct as RIAs), it does impose a number of extra guidelines and necessities on the adviser which are designed to guard traders and supply extra info to the SEC. For some traders, this can be an element they contemplate when selecting an funding adviser agency.
What are the downsides of registering?
Whereas registration opens up new alternatives by eradicating regulatory constraints and providing flexibility instead, it additionally imposes important money and time prices. One of many first impositions of registration is the requirement to nominate a chief compliance officer (CCO) and implement a compliance program tailor-made to the RIA’s enterprise. As of late, there are a plethora of compliance consultants who can help with the event of a compliance program and in addition can conduct coaching periods. There are also varied compliance instruments to help with the gathering, approval and oversight capabilities. What’s necessary for companies to know, nonetheless, is that the mere adoption of a compliance program won’t be enough. RIAs are anticipated to have a dynamic compliance program that adapts to adjustments of their enterprise and group, in addition to developments within the legislation and market.
Changing into a RIA will imply higher scrutiny by the SEC. Whereas ERAs are topic to examination and do get examined, RIAs are more likely to endure an examination. As a rule of thumb, RIAs ought to count on to be examined inside their first yr of registration and roughly as soon as each seven years thereafter. Throughout an examination, SEC employees will rigorously consider an adviser’s compliance with the myriad of authorized and regulatory necessities, together with many which are based mostly on fiduciary obligation rules and disclosures to traders relating to conflicts of curiosity. Most examinations will outcome within the adviser receiving a deficiency letter that lists the areas the place the adviser falls brief, though some can and do get referred to the Division of Enforcement.
A agency that registers will grow to be topic to numerous new guidelines underneath the Advisers Act, together with the code of ethics rule, custody rule, advertising and marketing rule and recordkeeping rule. Every of those guidelines entails ache factors {that a} new RIA might want to address. For instance, the code of ethics rule requires senior executives and sure different personnel to submit quarterly transaction experiences and annual holdings experiences for his or her private securities accounts and to preclear transactions in non-public placements and preliminary public choices. The advertising and marketing rule requires deal-level web returns to be proven with equal prominence when deal-level gross returns are proven (one thing companies usually don’t do and discover meaningless), locations limitations on the power to make use of a monitor document achieved at a previous agency, and triggers disclosure and oversight necessities when partaking a placement agent. The custody rule requires stub yr audits for funds that launch on the finish of the yr, regardless of prices and traders’ consent to prolonged audits, whereas the recordkeeping rule requires RIAs to handle how workers use off-channel communications like textual content messages, WhatsApp and different direct messaging purposes. (Please observe that the above will not be meant to summarize these guidelines or their quite a few challenges, which is past the scope of this put up.)
As well as, RIAs are topic to statutory necessities underneath the Advisers Act, pursuant to which they could be required to acquire investor consent when there are adjustments to their possession construction. The addition or elimination of an individual who owns greater than 25% of a RIA’s voting inventory may end up in a deemed task of an advisory contract requiring consent. Furthermore, for RIAs to obtain performance-based compensation, their traders should be certified shoppers (which can require traders to fulfill a web value commonplace that’s greater than double what they should fulfill for a fund managed by an ERA).
RIAs are also topic to extra reporting necessities. First, relatively than finishing simply parts of Half 1A of the Type ADV as ERAs do, RIAs should full the complete Half 1A, in addition to Half 2A (the brochure) and Half 2B (the brochure complement). Whereas these extra sections require extra time and a focus to finish, as soon as ready, they’re usually not as time-consuming to replace and maintain present. Second, RIAs should file a Type PF with the SEC, a confidential submitting that collects details about the non-public funds they advise. Though Type PF might be closely burdensome for giant hedge fund and personal fairness fund managers who might have to file the shape quarterly, most registered VC companies solely have to make the submitting yearly, and their prices for the reporting are usually not important.
In contemplating the general price of registering, companies ought to observe that previously couple of years, the SEC has had an unusually energetic rulemaking agenda. Underneath present Chair Gary Gensler, the SEC has proposed an extended listing of guidelines, a lot of that are slated to be adopted within the coming months. Though a few of these guidelines additionally would apply to ERAs, RIAs can be topic to considerably extra, and the cumulative burden of the brand new guidelines could also be prohibitive for a smaller agency newly registering. Amongst different necessities, if the proposed guidelines are adopted, RIAs can be required to ship quarterly statements to fund traders detailing varied charges and bills, get hold of equity opinions previous to closing on adviser-led secondary transactions, undertake cybersecurity insurance policies and procedures, disclose environmental, social and governance (ESG) practices and cybersecurity incidents and dangers of their Type ADV, custody all consumer property – not simply funds or securities – with a professional custodian, and conduct due diligence on outsourced service suppliers.
As well as, each RIAs and ERAs can be topic to new guidelines that, if adopted, would prohibit sure actions with respect to their non-public funds and place limitations on aspect letters. Amongst different issues, the prohibited actions rule would prohibit an adviser from charging a fund charges or bills related to SEC exams and any compliance bills incurred by the adviser, together with registration bills.
Ought to I register?
Given the variety of variables that go into deciding whether or not to register, it may be a sophisticated resolution. There isn’t a one-size-fits-all reply. With that mentioned, previous to the present administration on the SEC, an necessary facet {that a} agency might need thought of is the quantity of sources – money and time – that registration requires. Whereas compliance with extra necessities was an necessary consideration, it doubtless was not a determinative issue. At this time, nonetheless, companies would possibly contemplate not simply the money and time that will be required to register but additionally the chance that they might be capable of adjust to all the necessities relevant to a RIA, particularly if the proposed guidelines are also adopted. Dedicating a sure degree of sources is one factor; incapability to function a enterprise underneath the burden of compliance is one other. For a longtime VC agency with ample personnel exploring new alternatives, registration might present freedom from the 20% basket and suppleness to develop its enterprise. However for a smaller agency with restricted sources, would that flexibility be crushed by new restrictions and prohibitions that its personal workforce and compliance program won’t be capable of deal with? The reply right here is fully situational, and we’re right here to information companies by means of the varied issues in answering this troublesome query.
[View source.] 